For an assignment in my New Media Drivers License course offered by MSU, I created a Google AdWord Ad. This pay-to-click ad, that is supposed to appear on the right of the Google search page, was for my blog. Google makes it very easy to create an ad and offers many tools to make the ad as successful as possible.
Keywords are essential to the ad’s success. Google’s keyword research tool is very helpful. Using this tool, I found the original keywords I choose were not very popular for searches which was probably why I only had 3 impressions after 24 hours. I changed my keywords to align with the most popular searches. However, because the ad rotations are dictated by the dollars the ad owners are willing to pay for keywords, my ad still did not come up. For this experiment, I put a low $5 limit on my monthly click fees. One of the popular search keywords that related to my blog was email marketing which had 82,000 searches/month, but had a $11.55 per click suggested bid — this one click was higher than my total monthly amount. I also found adding a targeted word like healthcare dropped the search matches to 52 -230 searches per month, and the suggested bid per click rose significantly from $3 to $7.03. Using the keyword tool, I learned the competition for the keywords I wanted is fierce and expensive. I would need to spend a lot more money than my measly $5 budget for my ad to appear.
Trying to get my ad to appear was very frustrating. I spent hours and hours, days and days Googling my keywords. I understand most of my keywords would be taken by advertisers with much bigger budgets. But why wouldn’t my ad appear when I typed in my own name which I selected as a keyword. There was no competition for that?!?! This made me even double, and triple, check that my account was active.

Yes, my Google AdWord Ad is active, but why won't it appear?
Yes, it does say my account is active, yet the ad never appears. Google claims that the ad won’t appear on every search due to my budget, the amount per keyword I’m willing to pay and the number of competitors. However, again I wonder, why when I search Renee Shimmel does it not appear. Google took my $5 activation fee and will charge my account when hits occur, yet no hit can occur because they won’t put up the ad — not even when you look through pages and pages of sponsored ad links. According to my impression summary count, it supposedly is showing up for some web users, but I’m wondering if it is a just scam.
I always been a little skeptical on how effective these Google pay-for-click ads have been, now I’m even more skeptical. My multi-hospital organization has purchased these ads to promote videos on key healthcare services we offer. Our ads are on both Google and Yahoo; we also post the videos on our website and YouTube. Yahoo got more hits than Google and YouTube blew out both. Ultimately, our website does the best, although I must admit much time has been invested in search engine optimization to make it successful. Unfortunately, we can’t track if these web watchers turn into patients due to our patient tracking system.
Frustrated and skeptical about these ads, I decided to ask some friends a few questions about their web searches and use of the pay-for-click ads. I sent out 39 short surveys to see if they use Google’s search engine, do they look at the ads, did they ever clicked on the ads, and have they ever bought an ad for their company. I received 25 surveys back, everyone used Google’s search engine regularly. This informal survey revealed 32% of the respondents look at the ads and another 28% periodically look at them; 40% never look at them. Do they ever click on the ads? 36% said they did, 16% claimed periodically they clicked on them and 48% said never. Of the respondents, six had bought a pay-for-click ad. Half said it wasn’t successful for them, one said fairly successful and two others endorsed this marketing idea. One specialized online train retailer claimed he promotes his business exclusively through the web and his website tops 50,000 hits a day worldwide with much of his success due to the pay-for-click ads. I believe his success is due to the lack of competitors so can pay a minimal amount for his keywords to get in the top 3 on the first page. Also, some respondents told me they were more likely to pay attention and click on the ads when looking for a service/business than if they are just searching for information. This mentality would also contribute to success to drive buyers to his site. For healthcare though, most often organizations/doctors are supplying health information and thus are selling services in a soft sell approach rather than a hard sell approach, which the train retailer can do.
From this experience, I agree with one of my survey respondents who claimed: Google pay-for-click ads were more effective in the past than they are now. I believe it may be because of today’s large number of online competitors due to the fact the web is fast becoming one of the top resources for information. Thus, advertisers with small budgets can’t compete against the deep-pocket advertisers who appear in the top 3. If you can pay to be in the top 3, then you may have a chance of getting approximately half the web users to view and click your ad. In my opinion invest your resources and time in search engine optimization so your site will appear in the main search result area. Then you have 100% of the web users looking at your information and potentially going to your site.